Cost effective Design of Instrument Labs

The use of PACTA cabinets makes Instrument Labs more operational, cheaper and more flexible

 Many instrument laboratories performs analytical chemistry using:

  1. Mass spectrometry,
  2. liquid chromatography,
  3. gas chromatography,
  4. and other equipment.

Factors driving laboratory design

  1. Equipment requirements
    Specific environmental, utility and ergonomic configurations
  2. Work flow requirements
    Safe and efficient workflows, for personnel and for goods in/out
  3. Adjacency to users
  4. Cost

Instrument labs may not be purpose-built. During capacity scale-up, and to avoid new-build, normal laboratory space and even office space is re-purposed for instrument lab use, resulting in sub-optimal layouts, poor environmental control and inefficient utility deliveries.

Compromised lab spaces often result in

  • lower throughput,
  • OHS-issues,
  • and higher maintenance and operational costs.

In contrast, lab spaces designed specifically for instrumentation analytics offer the opportunity to match spatial, environmental and utility needs from day one, as proper programming is performed at the onset.

Lab programming includes consideration to workflows, growth, flexibility and maintenance, and to physical and mechanical requirements. The lab manager, the maintenance staff and lab planner / designer must do a comprehensive programming effort in order to optimize efficacy and long-term operational costs.

(Counters and) Cabinets

When it comes to instrument labs, it is ALL about the equipment.

The equipment is highly calibrated, very expensive and sometimes very large and/or heavy. All design elements, but particularly the cabinetry; need to be designed with the equipment in mind:

  • Stability. Accessibility. Ergonomics.
    The base cabinets selected for instrument labs must be able to remain level, and maintain stability to allow for the precise calibration for which some of these machines are known.
    They may need to be designed at non-traditional heights to accommodate the ergonomic operation of the equipment. Consider what can be altered, and what not; e.g. solvent bottles can be brought down, as long as they are above pump level.
  • Housekeeping
    Proper cabinetry helps keep things out of the way in the instrument lab. Avoid having waste containment buckets everywhere.
  • Most processes occurring in instrument labs are contained within the instruments themselves, reducing the risk/frequency of spillage. However, proper tubing must be assured, inspection of tubes must be easy, and an overflow alarm for liquid waste should be considered.

The use of PACTA Cabinets
eases the design challenges

  • Less space needed
  • Less HVAC capacity needed
  • Less HVAC cooling load needed
  • Simplified Utility piping
  • Comes modular and standardized
  • Streamlines workflows and housekeeping
  • Improves OHS
  • Uncompromised personal safety

Clustered Labs / Core labs

Use of PACTA:

Up to 45% increased density

All of the facility’s analytical instruments/requirements should be consolidated into clustered labs due to simplicity, unique layout, HVAC and utility requirements. The location should

  • maximize adjacency to users
  • maximize adjacency to vertical transportation when in multi-story buildings
  • allow convenient access to utility systems (HVAC, gasses, purified water system, etc.)
  • provide for the appropriate disposal of solid and liquid waste

Room layout

Use of PACTA:

Safe Manual Handling during all operations

Solvents and waste efficiently ventilated

Savings on footprints

Fine OHS-conditions, including ergonomics

Orderly, Manageably

Several factors drive the room layout:

  • Safe handling during operation and maintenance,
  • Accessibility of equipment,
  • HVAC requirements,
  • Ease of maintenance,
  • Ergonomics

Layout considerations:

  • Locate PACTA-cabinets either back-to-back or along the walls. The pulls-outs ensure the access for maintenance and calibration from side and rear, and the traditional circulation space around the equipment is not needed.
  • Place benches used for sample preparation, administration, logging, write-up space either in neighboring rooms, or in the open lab near the windows and perimeter walls to improve access and work flow.
  • Determine the appropriate bench height and depth to accommodate ergonomic use of the instruments. Consider adjustable PACTAs to provide the best conditions.
  • Adhere to proper equipment access guidelines; maintain a clear space in front of PACTA’s and benches of approx. 50 in. No maintenance space behind is needed. Remember, normally instrument lab modules are larger/wider than typical labs to accommodate the deeper benches and additional access aisles – this is not the case when using PACTA cabinets.
  • Group the appropriate instruments together considering the sizes (height and depth) and function (e.g., liquid or gas chromatograph) of equipment. The latter component also serves to streamline utility requirements and waste flows. Also, consider grouping equipment with intensive heat rejection to isolate/localize HVAC requirements.

Conditioning the Space

HVAC

Use of PACTA:

Less air capacity needed.
No temperature impact on room.

Less HVAC cooling load

Solvents and waste efficiently ventilated

Once the layout is set and the lab components are in place, it is time to consider the air itself. In an instrument lab, there are some key aspects of conditioning the space:

  1. airflow
  2. temperature and humidity requirements
  3. operations
  4. room pressurization.

In a lab environment, airflow is critical whether the room is occupied or not. In instrument labs, designing the optimum air change rates to create the proper room conditions should be based on the worst case scenario of these three factors:

  • Heat load of equipment. Equipment exhaust requirements.
    Typically, this factor is the worst case due to the high concentration of heat-producing equipment. Many instruments just dissipate the heat into the room and need to be factored into sizing the HVAC cooling load. Using PACTA’s, this issue is neutralized. The PACTA-cabinets collects the heated exhaust air from the instruments. The air does not contribute to the rooms temperature.
  • Maintaining appropriate air change rates.
    Industry guidelines exist as to the air change rate, however there are no code minimum or maximum requirements.

Gas Delivery System

Use of PACTA:

Gas supply from above. Flexible cord used when height adjustable.

PACTA-XX is released mid 2017 with the option to hold two gas cylinders locally, inside the cabinet

Gas Delivery System

Compressed lab air and lab gasses are essential to the operations of an instrument lab. Primary ways to deliver compressed gasses to the lab environment and distribute throughout are:

  • Central compressed gas systems
  • Point-of-use compressed gas cylinders located inside the lab.

Gas piping is routed above and below ceiling, depending on the room and on code. Installations should allow for visual inspection per the International Fuel Gas Code and for leakage testing.

The gas outlets are surface-mounted at the back of lab benches, some permanently connected to instruments. Flexible cords are more and more frequently used. Regulators and handles must be easily accessible.

Hazardous Liquid Waste Disposal

Use of PACTA:

Liquid waste canister is located below the instrument. Overflow alarm is optional.

Some lab waste materials goes into the municipal system. Hazardous waste requires special handling.

In QC labs using the same media, waste may be collected and piped out of the lab to a satellite accumulation area, in appropriate containers, separated by waste type. Tubing from the equipment generating the waste is connected via a sloped, waste collection pipe routed behind the lab bench.

In R&D labs, setups change frequently, and a centralized collection system imposes risk for mixing chemicals in the remote satellite, that should not be mixed. Waste must be collected locally, in a simple way not imposing handling hazards. Once the containers are full, they are removed from the lab by an authorized service.

Reference: “Designing the next generation instrument lab”, https://www.labdesignnews.com/article/2016/06/designing-next-generation-instrument-lab.
By Jim Schreyer, P.E., LEED AP (BD&C), is Project Manager with Hixson Architecture, Engineering, Interiors in Cincinnati, Ohio.